Our prediction: 'Don't You Wanna Stay' by Jason Aldean and Kelly Clarkson. This was the biggest song of the year in 2011, and took Jason Aldean's career to new levels. 'You and Tequila' voters will be split between its two categories, or focused on the Song of the Year award. Chris Young has the best chance of scoring an upset as voters may want to reward a star on the rise instead of Aldean and Clarkson.