Casey James walked into his 'American Idol' audition with his hair in a ponytail and his clothes on, but left like this. The blond Texan impressed the female judges with his model looks, and Randy Jackson agreed with them to push the singer and guitarist on to Hollywood. From there, he kept his clothes on throughout an entire season, finishing in third place before signing a record deal with Sony Nashville. Since then, James's female fans have been looking for a 'Then and Now' comparison of his upper body. No luck yet.