Before he kept a close crop of dark hair under his black cowboy hat, Tim McGraw had long, wavy locks and a cop mustache. This shot from his 'Indian Outlaw' video reminds us that the superstar wasn't always on the cutting edge of fashion.

In 1994, he looked like he could be a man mothers now warn their daughters to avoid. His now-charming smile seemed more mischievous. Would Faith Hill have fallen for this Tim McGraw, had he not begun to clean up before their tour two years later? Probably, but it's clear her fashion sense has rubbed off on him.