Bucky Covington – Then and Now

Fans of Bucky Covington never thought he looked creepy during the fifth season of 'American Idol,' but in comparison to his "Now" photo... maybe he did, just a little bit. His eyebrows look thinner and lighter and his smile is sharper, perhaps due to some dental work. Like Casey James (who appears later in this list), Covington remains dedicated to the long, blonde, curly hair -- although he'll still hoist it in a ponytail every once in awhile.